About Mummy & Blogger Babies

My photo

Blogger Babies and Mummy believe in sharing resources and ideas to enable the best possible care and support of our vulnerable.

To Donate to The Edith Ellen Foundation

Monday, 21 November 2016

Mental Capactity Act

Failings From the Top

How would you feel if you couldn’t return to your native country to live out the remainder of your life?  Because a country you are not a citizen of decided what was best for you with very little knowledge about you, your wishes and your beliefs?

With many Dementia Patients, they feel the need to feel safe and secure in a place they understand and a language they speak.  But doesn’t this sentiment not apply to us all?

Mental Capactity Act
How, is the Court of Protection and Social Services “safeguarding” the Subject in this case?  What is the legal basis for their argument?  And would the resources not have been better placed looking at the failing care system rather than subjecting a 70year old to this?

Why, did the Court of Protection need Mrs Kirk to “go and retrieve” the Subject?  Why was neither of them stopped at the boarder before being allowed to leave? 

Could it be because

1.       The Subject is in his home country and extradition needs to be agreed between the parties involved?
2.       They could not be stopped because the subject holds a Portuguese Passport not a British one.

I know my opinion, though former Liberal Democrat MP John Hemming words it better “it stinks”. 

Court of protection

Woman defied judge to take dementia patient to live in his native Portugal

A grandmother from Sussex has been jailed for six months after taking an elderly man with dementia to a care home in his native Portugal and refusing to bring him back to Britain. Teresa Kirk, 71, was found guilty of contempt of court after disobeying orders for the 80-year-old man - identified only as MM - to be returned to the UK. The man, born in Madeira, had lived in Devon for some 50 years and had a "large circle of friends" but did not have the "capacity to make decisions about his residence and care", according to court transcripts.

The legal issues began in 2014 after Kirk removed MM from his home to hers in the county. Then, last year they went to Portugal and she admitted him to a care home, where he remains and Kirk reportedly believed he was happy. However, this was in defiance of court orders and social worker recommendations it was in the man's best interests to live in a care home in south-west England.

Passing sentence at the Court of Protection, Mr Justice Newton, said: "I am left with no alternative but to pass a sentence of imprisonment, however much I have made it perfectly clear that I do not wish to do so." The judge said Kirk has "deeply held, sincere beliefs" and is "genuinely concerned" about the welfare of MM but there had been a "long period" where she had "successfully frustrated" court orders. The hearing was held at the Court of Protection on August 18 but the transcripts were only released on the court judgment website last week. The relationship between MM and Kirk cannot be published for legal reasons.

A spokesman for the Courts and Tribunals Judiciary reportedly said the online judgment had been held back from publication ‘so an error could be amended’.

Open justice campaigner and former Liberal Democrat MP John Hemming said: "What's very important about this case is the public have no idea as to the validity of the reasoning for the court order. I have a better understanding - and in my view it stinks. I have been worried about secret imprisonments for some time. In this case the judgment was held back from publication until some weeks after she was sent to jail."

The sentence was originally suspended for seven days to "give Mrs Kirk one last chance to comply", according to the transcripts. It is understood she is being held in Bronzefield prison in Surrey.

Wanda Maddocks, 50, from Stoke-on-Trent was the first person known to be imprisoned by the Court of Protection in 2012 after a judge ruled that she should go to prison for five months for contempt of court after trying to remove her father from a care home where his family thought he was in danger of dying.
Post a Comment